Skip to content

Proxmox vs VMware vs OpenStack: Migration to Open Source Solutions

🚨 The Context: VMware Changes

What's happening with VMware?

In 2023, Broadcom acquired VMware and announced significant changes to its licensing model that have deeply impacted organizations:

  • Elimination of perpetual licenses: Subscription-only licenses
  • Dramatic cost increases: Up to 10x more expensive in some cases
  • Product consolidation: Elimination of popular SKUs
  • Support changes: Restructuring of the support model

💰 Economic Impact

  • Annual costs: From $5,000 to $50,000+ for medium environments
  • Per-core licensing: New model based on physical cores
  • Premium support: Significant additional costs
  • Forced migration: Obligation to upgrade to new versions

🆚 Detailed Technical Comparison

Aspect Proxmox VE VMware vSphere OpenStack
License model Open Source (GPL) Proprietary (Subscription) Open Source (Apache 2.0)
Initial cost Free $5,000+ annually Free
Cost per core $0 $200-500+ annually $0
Commercial support €95-€1,200/year Included in license Various providers
Complexity Low-Medium Medium High
Learning curve Gentle Medium Steep
Community Active Limited Very active
Documentation Excellent Good Extensive

🏢 Proxmox VE: The Open Source Alternative

✅ Advantages

  • Free: No licensing costs
  • Easy to use: Intuitive web interface
  • All-in-one: Virtualization + containers + storage
  • Integrated backup: Robust backup system
  • High availability: Native HA included
  • VMware migration: Migration tools available

⚠️ Considerations

  • Support: Mainly community (commercial support optional)
  • Ecosystem: Smaller than VMware
  • Integration: Some enterprise integrations limited

💡 Ideal Use Cases

  • HomeLabs: Perfect for home and development environments
  • SMBs: Ideal for medium-sized companies
  • Small data centers: Up to 100+ hosts
  • VMware migration: Smooth and economical transition

☁️ OpenStack: The Cloud Platform

✅ Advantages

  • Massive scalability: Thousands of nodes
  • Industry standard: Adopted by large enterprises
  • Total flexibility: Complete control over infrastructure
  • Multi-tenant: Perfect isolation between projects
  • Standard APIs: Compatible with AWS/Google Cloud
  • Rich ecosystem: Hundreds of complementary projects

⚠️ Considerations

  • Complexity: Requires significant expertise
  • Resources: Needs dedicated teams
  • Implementation time: Months of configuration
  • Maintenance: Continuous operation required

💡 Ideal Use Cases

  • Large enterprises: Infrastructure at scale
  • Service providers: Public/private clouds
  • Organizations with dedicated teams: DevOps/SRE teams
  • Strict compliance: Total control over data

🔄 Migration Strategies

🎯 Migration from VMware to Proxmox

Phase 1: Evaluation (1-2 weeks)

  • Inventory of existing VMs
  • Dependency analysis
  • Proof of concept in laboratory
  • Resource planning

Phase 2: Preparation (2-4 weeks)

  • Proxmox installation on new hardware
  • Network and storage configuration
  • VM migration (v2v)
  • Functionality testing

Phase 3: Migration (1-2 weeks)

  • Gradual migration by services
  • Application validation
  • Backup configuration
  • Process documentation

Migration Tools

  • qemu-img: Disk conversion
  • virt-v2v: Direct migration
  • Proxmox Backup: Synchronization
  • Custom scripts: Automation

🎯 Migration from VMware to OpenStack

Phase 1: Design (4-8 weeks)

  • Cloud architecture
  • Component selection
  • Network and storage design
  • Security plan

Phase 2: Implementation (8-16 weeks)

  • OpenStack installation
  • Service configuration
  • Integration with existing systems
  • Load testing

Phase 3: Migration (4-8 weeks)

  • Workload migration
  • Application reconfiguration
  • Performance optimization
  • Team training

💰 Cost Analysis

Scenario: 50 hosts, 500 VMs

VMware vSphere (New model)

  • Licenses: $250,000/year
  • Support: Included
  • Total annual: $250,000

Proxmox VE

  • Licenses: $0
  • Commercial support: $60,000/year (optional)
  • Migration consulting: $50,000 (once)
  • Total first year: $110,000
  • Total following years: $60,000

OpenStack

  • Licenses: $0
  • Commercial support: $200,000/year
  • Implementation: $300,000 (once)
  • Total first year: $500,000
  • Total following years: $200,000

Migration ROI

  • Proxmox: ROI in 6 months
  • OpenStack: ROI in 2-3 years (for large environments)

🛠️ Tools and Resources

For Proxmox

For OpenStack

Migration Tools

  • VMware vCenter Converter: Basic migration
  • qemu-img: Disk format conversion
  • virt-v2v: KVM migration
  • OpenStack Heat: Migration orchestration

📊 Success Cases

Company A: SMB (20 hosts)

  • Before: VMware vSphere Standard ($50,000/year)
  • After: Proxmox VE ($0/year)
  • Savings: $50,000/year
  • Migration time: 3 weeks
  • Result: 100% functionality, better performance

Company B: Corporation (200 hosts)

  • Before: VMware vSphere Enterprise ($500,000/year)
  • After: OpenStack ($200,000/year)
  • Savings: $300,000/year
  • Migration time: 6 months
  • Result: Greater flexibility, total control

Company C: Startup (5 hosts)

  • Before: VMware vSphere Essentials ($5,000/year)
  • After: Proxmox VE ($0/year)
  • Savings: $5,000/year
  • Migration time: 1 week
  • Result: Scalability without license limits

🎯 Recommendations by Organization Type

Startups and SMBs

Recommendation: Proxmox VE - Reason: Zero cost, easy to use, complete functionality - Migration: 1-4 weeks - ROI: Immediate

Medium Companies (50-500 hosts)

Recommendation: Proxmox VE or OpenStack - Proxmox: If seeking simplicity and savings - OpenStack: If massive scalability needed - Migration: 1-6 months - ROI: 6 months - 2 years

Large Corporations (500+ hosts)

Recommendation: OpenStack - Reason: Scalability, total control, standards - Migration: 6-18 months - ROI: 2-3 years

🔮 The Future of Virtualization

  • Containers: Kubernetes dominating
  • Serverless: Function as a Service
  • Edge Computing: Distributed processing
  • Hybrid Cloud: Cloud combination

Impact on VMware

  • Market loss: Massive migration to alternatives
  • Strategy change: Focus on hybrid cloud
  • Competition: Proxmox and OpenStack gaining ground

Opportunities

  • Training: Demand for open source expertise
  • Consulting: Migration opportunities
  • Development: Contribution to open source projects

📚 Conclusion

Migration from VMware to open source solutions is not just an economic option, but a strategic necessity for many organizations. VMware's licensing changes have created a unique opportunity to:

Immediate Benefits

  • Significant savings: 60-90% cost reduction
  • Total control: No dependency on a single vendor
  • Flexibility: Adaptation to specific needs
  • Innovation: Access to latest technologies

Long-term Benefits

  • Scalability: No license limits
  • Community: Support from thousands of developers
  • Standards: Open and documented technologies
  • Future: Preparation for next trends

Final Recommendation

Don't wait any longer. VMware costs will continue to rise, and the longer you wait, the more complex the migration will be. Open source solutions like Proxmox and OpenStack are mature, stable, and production-ready.

Need help with your migration? Explore our technical documentation on Proxmox and OpenStack to start your transition to open source!